Comment Analysis · Docket FS-2025-0001

FS-2025-0001-511996

Opposes rescissionPosted September 29, 2026 On Regulations.gov

Not scored for substance: the comment does not clear the floor of substantive signal.

Topics

  • Environmental Protection Biodiversity
    • “supports the region's native biodiversity, including imperiled species”
    • “protect at least 10% of the region for the benefit of biodiversity”
    • “wildest, healthiest, and most intact landscapes”
  • Water Quality Quantity
    • “safeguards clean drinking water”
    • “protect drinking water for 8.8% of Vermont residents”
    • “water from sources that originate in Inventoried Roadless Areas”
  • Recreation Tourism Public Use
    • “famous Long Trail and Appalachian Trail traverse numerous Inventoried Roadless Areas”
    • “vital area for wildlife and human recreation”
    • “quiet, remote, and backcountry recreation values”
  • Cultural Heritage Indigenous
    • “protects culturally-important sites and subsistence use areas”
    • “critical to food security for many indigenous communities”
    • “sustaining cultural and spiritual practices”

What it names

National Forests
Hoosier National ForestWhite Mountain National Forest
Roadless areas
Green MountainWhite Mountain
Works cited
10.1186/s42408-026-00450-210.1371/journal.pwat.0000538

The comment

Acting Director, Ecosystem Management Coordination, USDA Forest Service Joshua White,Dear Joshua White, USDA Forest Service Acting Director of Ecosystem Management Coordination, and Members of Congress:I'm respectfully writing to oppose the US Forest Service's proposal to rescind the 2001 Roadless Area Conservation Rule (Roadless Rule). Please drop this plan or select Alternative 1, No Action.For a quarter century, the Roadless Rule has provided an essential layer of protection for approximately 58.5 million-acres of National Forest System lands, or about a third of all lands managed by the USDA Forest Service (Forest Service). “Inventoried Roadless Areas” (IRAs) protected by the Roadless Rule represent many of the wildest, healthiest, and most intact landscapes in the United States (https://www.pfpi.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Roadless-Rule-Rescision-Threatens-Preprint-Mildrexler-et-al.-2026.pdf). Over 1.5 million Americans submitted comments in support of the Roadless Rule when it was developed, a record for public participation in federal rulemaking that still holds to this day.In New England, the Roadless Rule protects 260,000 acres, or approximately one-fifth of the White and Green Mountain National Forests, combined. Iconic landscapes protected by the Rule include places like New Hampshire’s Franconia Notch, Mt Moosilauke, Mt Chocorua, and the Presidential Range, as well as Vermont’s White Rocks. The famous Long Trail and Appalachian Trail traverse numerous Inventoried Roadless Areas protected by the Roadless Rule. Equally important, the Roadless Rule safeguards clean drinking water, protects against floods and droughts, and supports the region's native biodiversity, including imperiled species like the Northern Long-eared Bat, brook trout, Canada lynx, Bicknell's Thrush, and American marten, among many others.Even Indiana benefits from this rule within the Hoosier National Forest - this is a vital area for wildlife and human recreation, a gift that could be lost without the continuation of this rule.Only 3.3% of New England is protected from timber harvest and road construction, but scientists say we must protect at least 10% of the region for the benefit of biodiversity, carbon storage, and the wellbeing of our communities. Rescinding the Roadless Rule would set our region back in time, making New England's conservation goals even harder to achieve.Recognizing the exceptional value of Inventoried Roadless Areas (totaling just 2% of the lower-48 states), as well as the Forest Service’s unsustainable multi-billion dollar road maintenance backlog, the agency promulgated the Roadless Rule as “a down payment on the well-being of future generations,” in the words of former Forest Service Chief Mike Dombeck, who oversaw the Rule’s development.The work the Roadless Rule is providing implements incredible, irreplaceable protections on an environment that means so much to me & all citizens in the midwest. For a part of the country that used to be completely covered in trees, we must protect the little patches we have left and keep it from being disturbed by human processes.A recent study found that in New England, the Roadless Rule helps to protect drinking water for 8.8% of Vermont residents and 7.3% of New Hampshire residents (https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pwat.0000538). Additionally, 7% of Massachusetts residents get their water from sources that originate in Inventoried Roadless Areas in the White Mountain National Forest.Importantly, the Roadless Rule is also among our best tools for addressing wildfire. Most fires are started by people, and a recent study found that fires are four times more likely to start near roads (https://doi.org/10.1186/s42408-026-00450-2). The Roadless Rule also protects culturally-important sites and subsistence use areas. These spaces are critical to food security for many indigenous communities as well as for sustaining cultural and spiritual practices, including hunting, fishing, and gathering forest plants for food, medicine, and traditional arts.I know the environment hasn’t been of the highest priority in Indiana as of late, but it is an integral part of who we are as a state and as a people. I implore you to please change this trend and protect our natural spaces.Please drop this plan to rescind the Roadless Rule or select Alternative 1, No Action.Finally, I am calling on my members of Congress to co-sponsor and pass the Roadless Area Conservation Act of 2025, H.R.3930 and S.2042, to codify the Roadless Rule in statute.Thank you.BriannaIndiana

Keep learning. Keep speaking up.The Roadless Rule depends on public engagement. Share what you've learned.

© 2026 roadless.org - Defending America's Last Wild Forests

Privacy Policy|Questions or concerns? noroads@roadless.org|Follow us: @defendroadless