Comment Analysis · Docket FS-2025-0001

FS-2025-0001-536036

Opposes rescissionPosted October 4, 2026 On Regulations.gov

Not scored for substance: the comment does not clear the floor of substantive signal.

Topics

  • Wildlife Habitat
    • “RR lands mean connectivity for species survival”
    • “Rescission displaces threatened species”
    • “ESA listed grizzly bear requires best science”
    • “will prove fatal for grizzly populations”
  • Environmental Protection Biodiversity
    • “cannot tolerate rescission in exchange for marketization of public lands”
    • “RR means protections not their removal”
    • “effects threatened species”
    • “retains the 2001 rule's protections”
  • Climate Carbon Storage
    • “effects threatened species and of climate change”
    • “analyze the site-specific environmental consequences”

What it names

National Forests
Beaverhead-Deerlodge National ForestBighorn National ForestBitterroot National ForestBridger-Teton National ForestColville National ForestCuster National ForestFlathead National ForestGallatin National ForestGifford Pinchot National ForestHelena National ForestKootenai National ForestLolo National ForestOkanogan National ForestOlympic National ForestShoshone National ForestTarghee National ForestWenatchee National Forest
Roadless areas
Big SnowiesBlack ButteBluff MountainBox CanyonCabin Creek Wildlife Management Area OcdCalf CreekCrazy MountainsEagle ParkEast PioneerFreezeout MountainGranite MountainGrizzly PeakHighwood BaldyLost Water CanyonMiddle Fork Judith WsaMiddle Mtn. / Tobacco RootsNorth Fork SmithPaine GulchPasayten RimPilgrim CreekRed Lodge Creek HellroaringSilver KingTenderfoot - Deep CreekTrout CreekTw MountainWest Slope TetonsWilderness Study Area

Attachments

1 file. Counts as 1 — Counts as one: The attachments enclose no one else's submissions; the comment counts as one.

  • Own letter

The comment

Re: Rescission of the Roadless Area Conservation Rule, Docket FS-2025-0001. 50 years living in NCDE & Yellowstone Region has given me solace based in truth so cannot tolerate rescission in exchange for marketization of public lands. RR means protections not their removal.RR lands mean connectivity for species survival. Rescission displaces threatened species. ESA listed grizzly bear requires best science. Rescission shuns it and will prove fatal for grizzly populations. Cited lands mirror grizzly DPS compliance. I am writing in opposition to the rescission of the 2001 Roadless Area Conservation Rule, specifically inventoried RR areas: Lost Water Canyon (9,251 acres), Custer NF, MTBurnt Mountain (10,698 acres), Custer NF, MT Black Butte (871 acres), Custer NF, MT Red Lodge Creek Hellroaring (17,210 acres), Custer NF, MTOkanogan-Wenatchee NF (1,006,000 acres), Okanogan NF, WAGifford Pinchot National Forest (213,000 acres), Gifford Pinchot National Forest, WAMt. Baker-Snoqualmie NF, WALiberty Bell (108,495 acres), Okanogan NF, WACuster Gallatin NF (848,000 acres), Custer Gallatin NF, MTBob Marshall Wilderness Complex (1,483,000 acres),Bob Marshall Wilderness Complex, MT Paine Gulch (7,875 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MTMt. High (33,484 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MTMcgregor - Thompson (27,211 acres), Lolo NF, MTDeep Creek (7,669 acres), Lolo NF, MT Trout Creek (30,851 acres), Kootenai NF, MTCataract (9,442 acres), Lolo NF, MTBlue Slide (17,505 acres), Wenatchee NF, WA Mt. Baker-Snoqualmie NF (415,000 acres), Mt. Baker-Snoqualmie NF, WA , Okanogan NF,Pasayten Rim (17,074 acres), Okanogan NF, WASawtooth (15,693 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MTwin Sisters (13,051 acres), Colville NF, WA Bridger-Teton National Forest (1,417,000 acres), Bridger-Teton National Forest, WyWest Pioneer (248,631 acres), Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF, MTBear - Marshall - Scapegoat - Swan (344,022 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Bob Marshall-Scapegoat-Swan (334,275 acres), Flathead NF, MT East Pioneer (145,082 acres), Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF, MTWest Big Hole (133,563 acres), Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF, MTMadison (127,859 acres), Gallatin NF, MTSelway-Bitterroot (114,953 acres), Bitterroot NF,MTHoodoo (105,162 acres), Lolo NF, MTAllan Mountain (104,184 acres), Bitterroot NF, MTSnowcrest Mountain (97,649 acres), Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF, MT Freezeout Mountain (97,305 acres), Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF, MT Middle Mtn. / Tobacco Roots (96,487 Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF, MTTuchuck (17,730 acres), Flathead NF, MTThompson Seton (52,235 acres), Flathead NF, MTMt. Henry (13,603 acres), Kootenai NF, MTOlympic National Forest (86,000 acres), Olympic National Forest,WASapphires (66,619 acres), Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF,MTBear Creek (8,123 acres), Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF, MT MTLittle Bighorn (133,949 acres), Bighorn NF, WyoSleeping Child (x1074) (21,433 acres), Bitterroot NF, MT, Bitterroot NF, MTDry Canyon Breaks (4,821 acres), Colville NF, WANorth Absaroka (21,063 acres), Custer NF, MTCrazy Mountain (82,093 acres), Gallatin NF, MTBridger (45,059 acres), Gallatin NF, MTHyalite - Porcupine - Buffalo Horn Wilderness Study Area (143,991 acres), Gallatin NF, MTGallatin Fringe (51,571 acres), Gallatin NF, MT Cabin Creek Wildlife Management Area Ocd (35,048 acres), Gallatin NF, MTWAHellgate Gulch (16,821 acres), Helena NF, MTBig Snowy Mountains Wsa (88,003 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MTCastle Mountains (29,409 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Crazy Mountains (24,942 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Box Canyon (12,584 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT- Big Snowies (9,258 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT North Fork Smith (8,444 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Tenderfoot - Deep Creek (85,614 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Eagle Park (5,912 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT- Calf Creek (10,108 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT- Pilgrim Creek (44,608 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Highwood Baldy (15,305 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Highwoods (24,378 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT- TW Mountain (8,388 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Granite Mountain (10,338 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Lewis & Clark NF, MT Middle Fork Judith Wsa (81,131 acres), Lewis & Clark NF, MT Bluff Mountain (38,060 acres), Custer NF, MtLine Creek Plateau (24,825 acres), Custer NF, MT, Custer NF, Mt Shoshone NF, WyoWilderness Study Area (51,961 acres), Targhee NF, Wyo- West Slope Tetons (47,448 acres), Targhee NF, Wy- Silver King (64,289 acres), Beaverhead-Deerlodge NF, Montana, - Selkirks (95,967 acres), Idaho Panhandle NF, Idaho-Grizzly Peak (7,441 acres), Kootenai NF, Montana I ask that the agency disclose and analyze the site-specific environmental consequences of the proposed rescission for each of these areas, including the effects threatened species and of climate change.I ask that the agency respond to each of them.I request that the agency respond in the record to each of the issues raised in this comment, and that it analyze in the DEIS an alternative that retains the 2001 rule's protections for the areas named above. Dan Sullivan Chanhassen, MN

Keep learning. Keep speaking up.The Roadless Rule depends on public engagement. Share what you've learned.

© 2026 roadless.org - Defending America's Last Wild Forests

Privacy Policy|Questions or concerns? noroads@roadless.org|Follow us: @defendroadless