To the U.S. Forest Service:
I strongly oppose any changes to the 2001 Roadless Area Conservation Rule that would weaken the protections it affords to forests on lands that are owned by the American people.
My home shares the South Toe River watershed with the Bear Wallow and Balsam Cone roadless areas in the Pisgah Ranger District in Yancey County, NC. In 27 years of hiking and camping, I have come to know these areas like beloved old friends.
The 14,704 acres of land protected by these two roadless parcels were crucial to protecting our valley from the worst effects of Hurricane Helene. These areas undisturbed forest withstood over 30 inches of rain in 48 hours with many fewer landslides than elsewhere in the county. In the South Toe valley, no one died in a debris flow. Sadly, on the other side of the Black Mountain Range, in the Cane River valley, which is not protected by the Roadless Rule, at least three people died in debris flows. On hikes since Helene, I have observed dozens of instances where landslides began where logging roads cut into the natural slopes of the mountainsides.
As a psychotherapist, I provide support to a client who lost her home to a debris flow in the Cane River Valley. Losing her home has exacted a major toll on her mental health, from which she still has not fully recovered two years later. Roadless areas protect not only native plants, animals, and other organisms, they also protect human life and wellbeing.
While Yancey County suffered Helene's worst flooding, neighboring forests in Mitchell County suffered massive blow-downs. As discussed above, these disturbed areas are incredibly vulnerable to infiltration by exotic invasive plants. If the biodiversity of USFS forests in Mitchell County ends up being compromised long-term by invasive exotic plants, it is more important than ever to protect adjacent roadless areas, including Slide Hollow, Wilson Creek, Lost Cove, Harper Creek, Linville Gorge Addition, Dobson Knob, Woods Mountain, Mackey Mountain, Jarrett Creek, and Craggy Mountain. The grandchildren and great grandchildren of Yancey, Mitchell, Avery, McDowell and Buncombe residents, of the United States -- and of the world -- deserve to know what a healthy, biologically intact Southern Appalachian Forest looks, smells, tastes, sounds, and feels like.
Hurricane Helene's flooding washed hellbender salamanders, lampreys, and tiny non-game native fish out of the river and onto our road. I'd never seen these elusive creatures up close before. Ten days after the storm, I witnessed huge hellbender climbing over boulders, possibly on an epic journey back to its home territory upstream. The purity of South Toe River water is a direct result of the protections to water quality provided by the Balsam Cone and Bear Wallow roadless areas. These roadless areas buffer the South Toe River's waters from sediment and other water pollutants, which allows the South Toe River to support rare and endangered salamanders, mussels, and fish that occur in only a select few other watersheds in North Carolina.
I am a passionate naturalist, deeply concerned about the threat to native botanical biodiversity caused by exotic invasive plant species. I have observed with dread as publicly-owned forests in Western NC are increasingly choked with Asiatic Bittersweet, Kudzu, Japanese Stilt Grass, Japanese Barberry, Japanese honeysuckle, and other invasive exotic plants. Where these plants flourish, they create a monoculture of themselves, threatening forest plant communities unique to the Southern Appalachians, as well as all the rare and endangered animals, birds, spiders, insects, herps, fungi and other organisms that have adapted to live within or migrate through them.
Fortunately, the relatively intact forests within the roadless areas at Bear Wallow and Balsam Cone appear to be fending off the worst invasive plant infestations. As the South Toe River Road has reopened, I have been dismayed to see new areas where invasive plants have begun to propagate, accelerated by the accidental introduction of seeds or plant material during road repair after Helene, and by extra sunlight where the South Toe River Road creates a break in the canopy. Right between Bear Wallow and Balsam Cone roadless areas, the South Toe River Road provides a perfect illustration of why roadless areas are imperative to preserve the remaining rich biodiversity of the Pisgah Ranger District.
These are the stories I know, but I know that all over the US, every roadless areas is providing equally crucial ecological services, protecting equally wild ecosystems, and bringing joy, health, and well-being to citizens who live near or visit them. I urge the U.S. Forest Service and the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to maintain full protections for all currently-designated inventoried roadless areas.
Thank you for accepting my comment.
Sincerely,
Jessica Ruegg